307 thoughts on “Where can I get high quality flannel shirts that aren't made in China and 100% cotton?

  1. Anonymous says:

    Well, the brand in your OP picture is a start. You need to expect to pay minimum $100 for something like that. If you’re cheap look for vintage woolrich or pendleton.

    • Anonymous says:

      Iron heart is the answer

      And no nothing cheaper

      350 for a flannel seems excessive. Especially since i know IH marks up their prices an absurd amount. If you were to buy IH domestically in Japan they’re half the price

      • Anonymous says:

        Are they really that much cheaper? Going to glorious nippon again I’m feb might have to check out their tokyo store.
        High quality flannel always escapes me here in aus so I end up buying $10 ones ar our walmart equivalent

      • Anonymous says:

        >If you were to buy IH domestically in Japan they’re half the price
        proofs?

        Are they really that much cheaper? Going to glorious nippon again I’m feb might have to check out their tokyo store.
        High quality flannel always escapes me here in aus so I end up buying $10 ones ar our walmart equivalent

        Surely nobody would go on the internet and lie

        • Anonymous says:

          Are they really that much cheaper? Going to glorious nippon again I’m feb might have to check out their tokyo store.
          High quality flannel always escapes me here in aus so I end up buying $10 ones ar our walmart equivalent

          half the reason IH is so expensive is because their international operations are based out of the UK. so the products are shipped to the UK, then shipped to consumers and retailers. that adds a huge markup to cover the shipping costs
          if you go to the IH stores in Japan they don’t have that markup. i believe it was in an interview with Giles (head of IH’s international operations) when he was asked straight up "why are they so expensive?". add in inflation and it just keeps going up

      • Anonymous says:

        Like I said in my post, if you’re too broke to pay for IH, look for vintage USA made pendleton and woolrich. You can find them in gently used condition for about $100, sometimes less.

          • Anonymous says:

            Not who you responded to but have found a few in good condition ~$30-50 on ebay with some digging. They can be hard to find in person but once found one for $70. Since it’s wool make sure to look out for moth damage.

        • Anonymous says:

          >proxies
          Do you mean like a VPN? Or a person that can purchase for you? Could you help a returning /fashion/scist out I’ve been out of the game (and the board) for almost a decade now.

          • Anonymous says:

            you pay a local jp to buy it at half price as this

            […]
            350 for a flannel seems excessive. Especially since i know IH marks up their prices an absurd amount. If you were to buy IH domestically in Japan they’re half the price

            anon claims

          • Anonymous says:

            step 1: establish contact with a proxy/intermediary service to establish an account
            step 2: order things and have them sent to proxy’s address in japan
            step 3: have them package it and ship it to you
            that’s enough spoonfeeding for now.

          • Anonymous says:

            Does the cotton have to be US too? That will also narrow your search.

            Who is actually doing this all for a flannel shirt. Are you guys really in that big a need of such high quality workwear materials? It’s not like anyone here is active enough that they’d destroy a regular flannel shirt in a year or something.

            Heavy weight 100% aspero cotton with double brushed interior for maximum softness, choice of western button snaps, minimum of double to triple stitching. It’s not too heavy, not too sweltering hot. Seems expensive, but when you put one on you’ll understand that its literally the perfect flannel. For $350 you could buy a mediocre suit that you might wear a couple times per year, or you can spend it on a flannel that you’ll wear most of the winter

            You can also spend 400 dollars on a cutting board

            >you could buy a decent suit with that kind of money
            very subtle bait but i’m sure someone fell for it

            >you could buy a decent suit with that kind of money
            No, but multiply that by two and you can get a very comfortable made-to-measure suit.

            https://i.imgur.com/UG2Tl04.jpg

            >you could buy a decent suit with that kind of money.
            bad bait

            Unless you literally have to wear a suit for your job every single day then yeah 400 will get you a good enough suit. “Oooh but you can tell the hand finishing on the buttonholes makes a world of difference, everyone in the world cares about half vs full canvas” grow up

    • Anonymous says:

      Man it’s a hecking shirt made out of cotton, you could buy a decent suit with that kind of money. What warrants all that cost

      • Anonymous says:

        Heavy weight 100% aspero cotton with double brushed interior for maximum softness, choice of western button snaps, minimum of double to triple stitching. It’s not too heavy, not too sweltering hot. Seems expensive, but when you put one on you’ll understand that its literally the perfect flannel. For $350 you could buy a mediocre suit that you might wear a couple times per year, or you can spend it on a flannel that you’ll wear most of the winter

      • Anonymous says:

        >you could buy a decent suit with that kind of money
        No, but multiply that by two and you can get a very comfortable made-to-measure suit.

  2. Anonymous says:

    Why is it so hard to find solid colored flannels? I just want a solid color, 100% cotton, not made in a sweatshop flannel
    I don’t want checks, i want solids

  3. Anonymous says:

    These are made in Canada but the patterns aren’t as /fashion/ as your OP pic. Straight up lumberjack plaids. Not sure about quality because I’ve never owned one.
    https://www.bigbill.com/ca_en/premium-flannel-work-shirt-121

    Not flannel but you can but these shirts that were made in America by prison labor for only $38
    https://www.prisonblues.net/product/4031111

    • Anonymous says:

      I got some filson shirts black friday. good quality, 7 oz I believe. will probably try
      big bill 9 oz next

      The BigBill ones are nice, and made in USA not Canada.

      • Anonymous says:

        I’m wearing the same flannel in the OP right now. REKT

        tell me about it, maybe you’ll change my mind. my issue with super heavy flannels is they are so warm that when you’re inside it’s like wearing a jacket you can’t take off and i start overheating
        that’s why i prefer thinner ones that i can layer a jacket over
        but if you own one and can convince me otherwise i might take the plunge

        Where I live cheaper flannels never cut it for me. They’re either never brushed enough to be comfy against the skin or the fabric is so loosely woven that even slight breezes cut through them like nothing. The weight of the UHF also allows it to drape much nicer, and there is nothing else on the market that has the same double brushing texture

          • Anonymous says:

            It’s the correct weight and it’s hard to put into words

            […]
            half the reason IH is so expensive is because their international operations are based out of the UK. so the products are shipped to the UK, then shipped to consumers and retailers. that adds a huge markup to cover the shipping costs
            if you go to the IH stores in Japan they don’t have that markup. i believe it was in an interview with Giles (head of IH’s international operations) when he was asked straight up "why are they so expensive?". add in inflation and it just keeps going up

            Sounds like a business opportunity for you to buy them in Japan and sell them for less than IH.

  4. Anonymous says:

    I have three of Iron Heart’s ultra heavy weight flannels. I’ve searched for years for the perfect flannel and have arrived at IH as the end all be all for flannels. The combination of the western button snaps, double brushed interior, and heavy weight of the shirt makes it feel like nothing else. Seriously the most comfortable button up shirt I’ve ever worn. Not to mention the extreme attention to detail with stitching and the overall structural integrity. On top of all that, these things legitimately look and feel better with each wash. OP, if you decide to cheap out and go with something less expensive, you are doing so knowing that you are buying something that stands in the shadow of what IH produces and you will not be satisfied until you finally just buy one.

      • Anonymous says:

        You could always buy one on grailed for like $200. Keep in mind that the japanese sizing on these is kind of weird. I wear a large in most American sizes, but I wear XXXL in these

      • Anonymous says:

        Yeah agreed. Although they are arguably the best flannels, they are also a perfect example of the point of diminishing returns

        • Anonymous says:

          Yea if I could get 13+ oz heavy flannels for $100 I definitely would. The 15.5 oz UES flannel I just got is pretty much unparalleled in my collection of flannels.

          • Anonymous says:

            Is a flannel that heavy really hot? I’ve got a bunch of Duluth ones (5.6oz lol), and they’re "just ok", not really warm, but I got most of them at $35 and the fit is really roomy for layers, so it’s fine.
            I’m really liking the look of UES as a brand, so I may go for those instead of IH.

          • Anonymous says:

            I wore just that flannel a t shirt and jeans out today and it was like 2-4 Celsius. It was more than enough, I really like it and will be keeping an eye out for any other colors in the future that stand out. I got this one.

            https://i.imgur.com/CkfA69C.jpg

            Ordered one of their 15.5 oz shirts, should be interesting to see how it feels. They have one that is indigo dyed that looks pretty nice as well.

  5. Anonymous says:

    Outerknown have comfy flannel shirts (call them blanket shirts). Lots of colour choices (including unpattenered). Somewhat wanky marketing.

  6. Anonymous says:

    Honestly Amazon Essentials flannel I’m REALLY pleasantly surprised with:
    https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08X5BSCZ9
    They’re made in Malaysia and they’re actually pretty soft. They won’t stand up to workwear pounding but I’ve got nothing but compliments for the couple I bought.

      • Anonymous says:

        They aren’t very /fashion/. I’d rather just spend the money at this point. Buying a bunch of shitty clothes then having to replace them year after year is stupid. I’m too old to give a shit about new styles. Give me the classics that never go out of style.

    • Anonymous says:

      I end up going with cheaper flannels like this because I end up doing random projects like car or home repair in my every day clothes. Only time I put on full shitty work clothes is when I’m doing major overhauls like pulling transmissions or doing lots of stuff with grease. I cant really fathom spending 350 on a single shirt when my dumbass would either never wear it for fear of messing it up, or work on something seemingly simple then get a bunch of grease on it or something

      • Anonymous says:

        that’s the inherent larp in all of this. unless youre loaded youre not gonna do shit in these clothes. you can argue that fashion is a rich person interest and that im poor (both true), but why american style workwear in that case? doesnt that relegate all fashion to rich people larping as one thing or another?

        meanwhile the lived-in experiences that these clothes are associated with are now happening in shitass dickies, keens and costco brand midlayers. im conflicted. iron hearts and momos look cool and are made better but also they are extremely gaygy and generally worn by trustfund pooraboos

        • Anonymous says:

          the wealthy have been dressing up as poor people for as long as fashion has existed as a concept.

          the best part is that because you literally don’t whave to pay luxury prices for function, vintage Pendleton, Woolrich, Johnson Woolen Mills, Filson etc can all be found at 20+60 bucks a piece.

          Protip: a genuine Irish Aran cable-knit mops the floor with any flannel, in form and function.

          • Anonymous says:

            the filters on ebay search are pretty good, there are filters for material and country of origin, it’s great for seeking out genuine articles of often-replicated styles, like cowichan and Andean sweaters, and of course Irish knits.

            that being said, some brands I own a few pieces of include:
            Carriag Donn
            Inverallan
            Magee
            Irish Homecrafts
            Doogan

            some good keywords would be hand-knit, hand-loomed, Donegal, crew neck, shawl neck,. cardigan.

        • Anonymous says:

          Yeah I actually just worked on a car today in a Costco flannel, but threw on my old redkap jacket from when I worked at jiffy lube back in college for when I had to do suspension on the ground. Even when I met my friend out for beer last week I’d feel like a gay wearing a $300 shirt. Prob just will try to learn the brands and maybe find decent old used at goodwill or have my wife look.

    • Anonymous says:

      Depends on the type of denim jacket. If you’re talking about a denim jacket without any fleece lining, then yeah its warmer. I live in the PNW and usually wear an IH flannel with a 22 oz denim jacket and will stay warm through the winter. The flannel itself is not going to keep you warm in winter, but using it to layer with a jacket will do the trick unless you live in Wisconsin or Minnesota in which case you would want to wear a parka over that

  7. Anonymous says:

    Real McCoys has 20 oz flannel shirts
    https://therealmccoys.com/collections/tops/products/8hu-heavy-weight-flannel-shirt-1

  8. Anonymous says:

    lol at everyone in this thread wearing COTTON flannel. how hecking dumb can you be. this is clearly /fashion/ and not /out/ as you are comitting the number 1 sin of going /out/ which is cotton kills. if you get hypothermia on your next hike im not coming to save you but instead i will laugh and piss on your grave in my exceptionally warm WOOL flannel

  9. Anonymous says:

    Kuhl is a good choice. Great quality, not made in China, and great fit. Not IH quality, but come in around $80-$130. It’s all I wear now.

        • Anonymous says:

          synthetic fibers are terrible for the environment, not good for your skin, smell bad and aren’t as durable as natural fibers.
          they have no positives outside of gym clothing and certain applications. brands use them to save money at the cost of quality. period
          you couldn’t pay me a million dollars to wear plastic

          • Anonymous says:

            >aren’t as durable
            The other stuff you said was true but this is false. Polyester and nylon are stronger than cotton and the difference becomes even greater if you’re comparing wet synthetics to wet cotton.

          • Anonymous says:

            Nylon isn’t as bad as polyester. I own a nice Nylon bomber by buzz ricksons and it doesn’t have any of those faults. I’m assuming worse companies skimp and get low quality synthetics

  10. Anonymous says:

    Don’t wear flannel in 2023 unless you want to be pressed by horny gay dudes every time you walk down the street.

    Flannels are uses to signal to other gay dudes that you are in fact gay yourself.

  11. Anonymous says:

    I’m tempted to drop some cash on some Ironheart stuff, but I’m super paranoid I’d order it, get super excited for it to arrive and then it’s small as heck on my out of shape ass

    • Anonymous says:

      just take your best fitting pair you own currently, take all the measurements and compared them to the measurements on the site and size accordingly
      it’s not rocket appliances

    • Anonymous says:

      This

      synthetic fibers are terrible for the environment, not good for your skin, smell bad and aren’t as durable as natural fibers.
      they have no positives outside of gym clothing and certain applications. brands use them to save money at the cost of quality. period
      you couldn’t pay me a million dollars to wear plastic

      is the advice you need. Just keep in mind what type of fit you’re looking for. If you’re considering getting one of their slim or slim tapered fits, be honest about whether this could be a little too tight. I’ve owned a pair of their slim tapered jeans and wore them for a few months only to find out that I absolutely hate the fit and prefer their straight tapered fit infinitely more since it gives me workable crotch mobility and doesn’t have the feminine appearance of having the thighs too tight and the calve region being loose. If you order a pair only to find out you should have gone just one size up in waist, Iron Heart’s customer service is top notch. If you’re american, you could order a pair from Self Edge, Iron Shop Provisions, or Division Road and not have to deal with the longer shipping times from shipping overseas to Iron Heart’s HQ in the UK.

    • Anonymous says:

      https://i.imgur.com/E53Kwxy.jpg

      This […] is the advice you need. Just keep in mind what type of fit you’re looking for. If you’re considering getting one of their slim or slim tapered fits, be honest about whether this could be a little too tight. I’ve owned a pair of their slim tapered jeans and wore them for a few months only to find out that I absolutely hate the fit and prefer their straight tapered fit infinitely more since it gives me workable crotch mobility and doesn’t have the feminine appearance of having the thighs too tight and the calve region being loose. If you order a pair only to find out you should have gone just one size up in waist, Iron Heart’s customer service is top notch. If you’re american, you could order a pair from Self Edge, Iron Shop Provisions, or Division Road and not have to deal with the longer shipping times from shipping overseas to Iron Heart’s HQ in the UK.

      just take your best fitting pair you own currently, take all the measurements and compared them to the measurements on the site and size accordingly
      it’s not rocket appliances

      heck I meant to reference the next comment instead

  12. Anonymous says:

    I’m looking for a plaid shirt with this exact or identical pattern. imo it has the perfect balance of black and white; most black plaids have way too much white in them.

  13. Anonymous says:

    This is the brand I wear as a high-alpha LA male.

    https://deviumusa.com

    UK based and mostly made-in.
    https://finisterre.com/en-us

  14. Anonymous says:

    >Shirt came with black catseye button because some guy died of a fent overdose after trying to pass a fake fiver
    >Swapped them out for mother of pearl buttons because white buttons are right

    • Anonymous says:

      Rogue Territory is probably my favorite brand. I own one of their waxed jackets (the James Bond jacket) and some selvedge denim from them
      All their stuff is made in the USA, all from amazing fabrics and it’s all amazing quality. I absolutely recommend their stuff

  15. Anonymous says:

    I guess the appeal is to but one $300 dollar shirt and be done with it. Or I could just buy multiple 30-50 dollar shirts which would probably cover the same amount of time. Easier to have variety also when the items are cheaper.

    • Anonymous says:

      That $300 shirt feels really really nice though. I guarantee it feels better than the $30-$50 shirts (unless you bought them used and they’ve old)

  16. Anonymous says:

    They got a whole bunch of good ones on sale right now, and I can confirm they are as premium as you can get for a shirt-making company – they make shirts for nobility, yo

  17. Anonymous says:

    Tractor supply has 8.5 oz flannel shirts for $19. Ridgecut toughwear. Nobody on the street will ever know the difference.

    • Anonymous says:

      Isn’t most of their stuff made in Vietnam or something? The company is a Canadian company but I don’t think it’s all made there

        • Anonymous says:

          Yeah, I’m actually wearing it today. The material is really nice looking, probably more of mid-heavyweight, not brushed. The fit is perfect on my frame. Dutil has them on sale rn, and one of their other indigo dyed flannels for a bit less.

          https://dutildenim.com/collections/naked-famous-jeans-usa-canada/products/n-f-easy-shirt-heavy-vintage-flannel-blue-rust?variant=43742364533013
          https://dutildenim.com/collections/naked-famous-jeans-usa-canada/products/n-f-easy-shirt-real-indigo-dyed-plaid?variant=44002262057237

    • Anonymous says:

      My favorite brand of all time. I own several of their pieces and they’re as good as it gets. Not Iron Heart tier heavy, but made with cool materials, weaves, patterns, etc. Quality is insane.
      It took every single ounce of restraint in me to not buy one of their new waxed canvas jackets they just dropped because I already own one and literally have no justification for a new jacket, I just want one

        • Anonymous says:

          They do that on purpose the same way IH does super heavy fabrics, it’s their thing. I guess you like it or you don’t. I don’t own one of their flannels though, but their jackets and selvedge jeans. Good stuff

    • Anonymous says:

      Be careful with the sizing because everything Rogue Territory makes is made for very skinny lanklets. If you have broad shoulders, you cannot wear their shirts (some of their JACKETS don’t come with shoulder measurements above 18", ridiculous)

      Gitman Bros made a shirt out of this exact same flannel fabric a year or two ago and it’s very nice though. Gitman has more reasonable shoulder sizes.

    • Anonymous says:

      Be careful with the sizing because everything Rogue Territory makes is made for very skinny lanklets. If you have broad shoulders, you cannot wear their shirts (some of their JACKETS don’t come with shoulder measurements above 18", ridiculous)

      Gitman Bros made a shirt out of this exact same flannel fabric a year or two ago and it’s very nice though. Gitman has more reasonable shoulder sizes.

      The thing about RGT, Gustin, and 3sixteen is that they are products of the 2010s hipster era. Which means you will get slimmer fits, lower rise, and small collars as per the hipster aesthetic. The quality is better than anything at a mall but they are the specifically made and geared towards aging millennials

      • Anonymous says:

        Yeah, I’ll add Division Road to that list. They have small collars but carry some good stuff otherwise. I didn’t care about clothes at that point so I’m retroactively finding these brands that are still alive and have some good fabrics, but they make these crazy skinny fits. It’s crazy how successful the movie marketing for the RGT Supply Jacket has been. It’s a jacket for anorexic thin people.

  18. Anonymous says:

    since we’re talking about iron hearts here. are there any other comparable denim makers in japan? maybe similar quality and same price range more or less.

    • Anonymous says:

      yeah loads. samurai, momotaro, studio d’artisan, fullcount, warehouse, tunuki, oni, etc
      iron heart is just one of many doing not just incredibly high quality (and expensive) denim, but clothing in general

      • Anonymous says:

        would you choose any of them over iron hearts? i just want to buy one pair (ideally the best all around) and be done with it.

        • Anonymous says:

          That would be Connor’s Sewing Factory. They are a small family operation that reproduce 1:1 vintage Levi’s models from the 40s and 50s

      • Anonymous says:

        I had a pair of Momotaro jeans and they were amazing. They shrank in the wash and i gained weight so i had to get rid of them which sucked
        You could buy any one of those brands and be satisfied. They’re all on an extremely high level of quality. Iron Heart specifically does super heavy denim. That’s their niche, but that doesn’t mean the rest aren’t every bit as good
        Samurai is amazing and will probably be my next pair. Pure Blue Japan is also really interesting. Honestly just look at the brands and find what you think you’ll like and go for it. You can’t go wrong
        Don’t forget there are some great American brands making equally as high quality stuff also of Japanese denim. Check out Rogue Territory, 3Sixteen, Freenote Cloth and others. Same quality, just American brands

        • Anonymous says:

          Went through a few pairs of samurais back in the day, loved em. Really top tier brand.
          Try to shop on rakuten, Japanese yen is in the shitter right now, you can save 1/3 or more importing Japanese clothes from JP retailers right now.

          • Anonymous says:

            samurai is based how they literally grow and pick their own cotton by hand so they can control 100% of the manufacturing process to make things as high quality as possible

    • Anonymous says:

      This
      Ok with wool? Go for vintage Pendleton and Woolrich and you’ll be able to get shirts worth 100+ for 30-40 bucks that will last for decades.

      • Anonymous says:

        >you’ll be able to get shirts worth 100+ for 30-40 bucks
        T. Guy who hasn’t ahopped for vintage clothing in 10 years

  19. Anonymous says:

    https://www.portugueseflannel.com/

    I’m surprised no one knows this store.
    Here for the eu boys.
    good quality, prices won’t break you
    Not made in china like op asked

  20. Anonymous says:

    OP here. I made this thread almost a month ago and it’s still up. I’ve since bought and had delivered 2 different shirts in the time since I made this thread
    Guess we should make a flannel general or something since apparently this board likes flannels

      • Anonymous says:

        LL Bean chamois shirt. They’re amazing, I’m gonna get another. I don’t give a shit they’re made in Sri Lanka because they’re so good
        I got another shirt from a brand called Imogene and Willie and it’s really good but the QC was disappointing for a shirt that price. Lost two buttons in a week and there were loads of loose threads. Great shirt shirt but they need to fire their button sewer

      • Anonymous says:

        you’re walking down the street and see someone wearing this shirt
        is your first thought "that sure looks well worn and broken in" or is it "ew that shirt looks dirty, it probably smells"?

        • Anonymous says:

          It would depend on how the rest of the person looked. It definitely could look gross if the wearer had greasy hair and looked unwashed, but if they looked clean and the shirt was simply clean and faded then it looks cool.

          LL Bean chamois shirt. They’re amazing, I’m gonna get another. I don’t give a shit they’re made in Sri Lanka because they’re so good
          I got another shirt from a brand called Imogene and Willie and it’s really good but the QC was disappointing for a shirt that price. Lost two buttons in a week and there were loads of loose threads. Great shirt shirt but they need to fire their button sewer

          The chamois shirts rule. They’re such nice overshirts that I often use one like a jacket. They are tough and cheap enough to use for work, but also comfortable enough to relax or sleep in.

        • Anonymous says:

          Depends on the context. If the shirt along with the entire outfit is legitimately dirty, then it would be gross. This shirt is just well worn in though and looks rather sick

          • Anonymous says:

            faded and dirty aren’t the same thing. If the faded spots look pure white, then it is clean and faded. If the faded spots look yellow and brown from sweat and dirt, then it looks faded and filthy.

    • Anonymous says:

      The only thing that even come close to competing with cotton is linen and it’s mostly a summer fabric
      Wool > cotton > linen

  21. Anonymous says:

    Do proxies still exist for buying IH? I know you used to be able to buy it cheaper from third-party sellers before they locked them out a few years back.
    I’d really like to get one of those flannels, but $360 is quite steep.

    • Anonymous says:

      You can buy with proxies, lots of stores on rakuten will ship to you directly. Should save a lot of money that way right now, the yen is weak
      Use shoppinginjapan

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *