What modern day branch and area of Islam is the closest to the one practiced in 9th century Baghdad?


Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_date" on null in /var/www/wptbox/wp-includes/comment-template.php on line 1043

Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_date" on null in /var/www/wptbox/wp-includes/comment-template.php on line 1043

Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_date" on null in /var/www/wptbox/wp-includes/comment-template.php on line 1043

What modern day branch and area of Islam is the closest to the one practiced in 9th century Baghdad?

  1. 5 days ago
    Anonymous

    All of them.
    >And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided. And remember the favor of Allah upon you - when you were enemies and He brought your hearts together and you became, by His favor, brothers. And you were on the edge of a pit of the Fire, and He saved you from it. Thus does Allah make clear to you His verses that you may be guided.

    • 4 days ago
      Anonymous

      >All of them.
      All of them? So Ismaili Shiism is closest to the one practiced in 9th century Baghdad? So the Twelver Shiism that was heavily influenced by Persian culture, that's equally close to the Islam practiced in 9th century Baghdad? So the relatively anti-Arab islam of Indonesia is equally close to that original Islam as the hardcore Wahhabism of Saudi Arabia? So the Shiism that involves chanting the name "Ali" and beating your bare chest in a crowd of sweaty dudes, and the plain Sunni practice of simple prostration and prayer in a mosque; these two forms of Islam are equally close to the Islam of 9th century Baghdad? Yeah I don't think so. There are significant differences in the many sects of Islam today. They can't be equally similar to the original Islam. One has to be more so. And you know that a Quran quote that says "akshually Islam will never be divided lol" is not fucking evidence that there are no significant differences in Islamic sects today.

      • 4 days ago
        Anonymous

        Twelver shia dominated iraq in the 9th and 10th centuries.

        • 4 days ago
          Anonymous

          Sure. Then say that. “Twelver Shiism, and not modern Sunnism, is the closest thing to the Islam of 9th century Baghdad.” Done.

      • 4 days ago
        Anonymous

        I accept anyone who professes the shahadah as my Muslim brother. This will piss of literally everyone, but I don't care. Anyone who professes the shahadah is a Muslim. If their beliefs seem heretical to you, debate them polititely. No more than that.

        • 4 days ago
          Anonymous

          I accept you too UwU

  2. 4 days ago
    Anonymous

    Left is better than right but why ?
    Cant be hair color since i prefer brunettes usually

    • 4 days ago
      Anonymous

      dolicephalic

      • 4 days ago
        Anonymous

        Again those are usually horse faced uggos so it can be this
        I prefer babyfaced women

        right looks seductive left looks more innocent

        Right just look random af

    • 4 days ago
      Anonymous

      right looks seductive left looks more innocent

  3. 4 days ago
    Anonymous

    Sunni Hanafi Ash'ari

  4. 4 days ago
    Anonymous

    Why does LULZ think they're entitled to ideal women like this? What makes you a worthy husband?
    >muh 40k stock portfolio stem degree
    Equivalent of being good pussy.

    • 4 days ago
      Anonymous

      >ideal women
      >russian

    • 4 days ago
      Anonymous

      she either ended up with some vodka swilling gopnik or some fat russian mafia pushing 50 if he isn't already there, what difference does it make

  5. 4 days ago
    Anonymous

    Basically what's the most pro science/humanities, pro college/madrasa, pro Sufism Islam?

    Also pro music.

    • 4 days ago
      Anonymous

      Nizari Ismaili.

      • 4 days ago
        Anonymous

        Some people here claimed that they aren't real muslims. Not sure what to believe.

        • 4 days ago
          Anonymous

          Ask them who the "real Muslims" are.

      • 4 days ago
        Anonymous

        they're anti-Tasawwuf, also didn't exist until the 9th century

        • 4 days ago
          Anonymous

          >anti-tasawwuf
          Depends on what you mean by tasawwuf. They have tasawwuf inherent in their normal practice.
          >didn't exist
          They did exist. They just weren't a distinct sect. In terms of fiqh, they're just Jafaris following a different lineage from Twelvers, making them older than any Sunni sect.

  6. 4 days ago
    Anonymous

    Someone who identifies as Sunni, sticks to one of the 4 madhabs, identifies as either Athari, Ash'ari or Maturidi in Aqidah and follows an established Sufi Tariqa

    • 4 days ago
      Anonymous

      What country has those people the most per capita?

      • 4 days ago
        Anonymous

        Indonesia.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *