Was Afrocentrism really so common and mainstream in classical studies that this book had to be written as a response to it?

Was Afrocentrism really so common and mainstream in classical studies that this book had to be written as a response to it?

  1. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    Something doesn't need to be hegemonic in order to be criticized.

  2. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    I have two opinions which can be considered "Afrocentric."

    1. The human species' homeland is in Eastern Africa
    2. Ancient Egypt is the place where Western civilization originated from.

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      Neither of these onions are particularly controversial and shouldn't be regarded as "Afrocentric".

      • 8 months ago
        Anonymous

        I mean theorum is pretty damn onions I'd say

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      I disagree with both

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      I thought western civilization originated in Sumeria

      • 8 months ago
        Anonymous

        This
        Dont we have evidence of sumeria being the first civilization?

      • 8 months ago
        Anonymous

        This
        Dont we have evidence of sumeria being the first civilization?

        Both developed independently. The Greeks largely got their forms and took heavily from the Egyptians, and not the Mesopotamian states

        • 8 months ago
          Anonymous

          I'd agree for the most part. There also seemed to be some influence from Anatolia and the Levant

          • 8 months ago
            Anonymous

            >influence from Anatolia and the Levant
            Yeah its called "Orientalizing period".

        • 8 months ago
          Anonymous

          egyptians took a lot of cultural aspects from the sumerians, the horse carts and the writing technique, egyptians used pre fabricated stamps to write their glyphs just like sumerians did it before to write their language, just more refined, even the sin god is a sumerian concept adopted by the egyptians

          • 8 months ago
            Anonymous

            sun god*

          • 8 months ago
            Anonymous

            on top of that the first recorded semitic language is not egyptian but akkadian which originates in sumeria and is a post sumerian language meaning that by the time egypt got its first pharao Sumeria was already a strong civilization

          • 8 months ago
            Anonymous

            Egyptian glyphs are an isolate. They were probably inspired by the concept of written language itself but its earliest form takes no cues from cuneiform.

      • 8 months ago
        Anonymous

        Why do Amerimutts love to claim civilizations they have nothing to do with?

        • 8 months ago
          Anonymous

          What did that post have to do with America you obsessed brown homosexual

          • 8 months ago
            Anonymous

            Because Americans love to claim everything under the sea as "western civilization". Especially if they feel they can stroke their own ego with it.

            • 8 months ago
              Anonymous

              >my culture is soo much better than western culture I'm not going to tell you what it is
              Every time.

              • 8 months ago
                Anonymous

                That's not what he said you dumbass.

        • 8 months ago
          Anonymous

          >t. Seething cinkoid

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Ancient Egypt is the place where Western civilization originated from.
      Elaborate

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Ancient Egypt is the place where Western civilization originated from.
      Western civilization as we know it is derived from the Celts and Germans, with some Helleno-Roman trappings.

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      excellent bait

  3. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    Afrocentrism has been more or less relegated to the margins (who do you ever hear espousing it but blackcel egypt search weirdos?), but there needs to be something like this directed towards certain agenda-driven historians who try to argue that Greeks & Romans were POC or that Medieval Europe had comparable levels of racial diversity to the modern United States.

  4. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    How does anyone with a 7th grade understanding of history or geography not understand that Afro=/=black. Look at the goddamn Egyptians or Tunisians and tell me they look just like Kenyans or Congolese or African Americans. Also look at the gigantic desert kek

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      Don't you get it anon!? All people who share a continent are the same! Indians and Japanese are the same race!

    • 8 months ago
      Black Chvd

      >Afro=/=black
      Why not when people think of Afro they think Black it's common sense.

      >goddamn Egyptians or Tunisians
      Literal muttoids.

      > Kenyans or Congolese or African Americans.

      Bruh the Kenyans and Congolese don't look like each other let alone African Americans. Some look like Nilotic/Horners.

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      It's an American thing.

  5. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    Given that there are probably tens of millions of people who believe this shit, yeah I think it's fairly justified.

  6. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    no its not you stupid fucking nagger africa has been ignored by literally all except coomers and porn addicts

  7. 8 months ago
    Black Chvd

    >Sees generic greek/roman on the cover
    discarded, anyone with study worth reading in terms of historical/scientific debate wouldn't have that it reeks of insecurity.

  8. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    Afrocentrism entered the liberal curriculum in the 60s to in order to placate black groups who would threaten school staff with guns and bomb threats. It's one of the "BIG" lies that cannot be challenged.

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous
      • 8 months ago
        Anonymous
    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      Why do they never teach us this in school but have entire chapters dedicated to the KKK and shit?

      • 8 months ago
        Anonymous

        You know why. Reality is what they declare it to be.

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      What book is this from?

      • 8 months ago
        Anonymous
        • 8 months ago
          Anonymous

          Thanks, had never heard about this incident before

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      >black panther
      whatever that shit is
      they are pathetic

  9. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    I have a book about Egypt from back in the 90s. There was a section in the introduction dedicated to Afrocentrism and how the Egyptians weren’t black so kangz shit must’ve been pretty significant at one time.

  10. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    What's the point of seeing history from the perspective of Africans? Does that give a meaningful insight into anything?

    • 8 months ago
      Anonymous

      It's an often manufactured history that is presented as real scholarship. Eg. One of the most enduring Afrocentric lies is that of the black Egyptian.

  11. 8 months ago
    Anonymous

    The author answers your question here:
    https://www.historyplace.com/pointsofview/not-out.htm

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *