Isn't Metal a bit repetitive and lacking dynamics? All sounds more or less the same and too much strident. Classical music and good Rock is 10000 times better than Metal.
Isn't Metal a bit repetitive and lacking dynamics? All sounds more or less the same and too much strident.
Breathing is also repetitve, you should stop doing it
Fippy bippy
Yes, one of the dullest genres there is.
It's extremely dynamic if anything,you're right that it's heavily repetitive though. All genres have their limits I think. Metal does things Pop Music,Country,or Rap probably aren't going to do or at least wouldn't start doing organically do it can help develop new ideas in music for sure but not all music needs to be Metal either.
>It's extremely dynamic if anything
Not really, meal tends to be loud and stay loud all the way through the tracks, with some notable exceptions like Metallica.
>with some notable exceptions like Metallica.
One of the greatest but you just prove you don't know shit
Uhhhhhhhhh:
Ulvers Bergtatt
Virtually all of Nu Metal
Every even veuagly similar Black Metal Band to Ulver that used folk atmospheric elements prettymuch (maybe not all but like 80%)
Most Glam/Hair Metal
Black Sabbath
I literally said Ulver aswell lol.
oh so you have never actually listened to a single metal album
>oh no based and redpilled music is too loud
average metal non-enjoyer
Such a retarded view, what he was saying is, metal within that loud framework allows for much more experimentation and extra moments of dopeness, sorta like free jazz in that way. But that's not even counting all the brilliant acoustic, traditional musicality, dissection does that better then opeth imo but you just have get a concrete up ya and deal with some dissonance if you want your pussy perspective to be satiated, with all things, the sea of possibilities becomes clear with practice, not everything is simple cannibal corpse blast beat growling, but even take cannibal corpse as a prime example, without ever breaking from that framework they made extremely catchy death metal, like check out under the rotted flesh, you can't simply call that "loud without ever changing"
>like Metallica
Has to be bait
Most genres have music that is relatively consistent in sound. It's the cutting edge stuff that changes it up, and it's no different in metal.
the keyword in your comment is most
>metal isn't dynamic
great post
Metal still suffers heavily from loudness war mastering despite streaming making it obsolete. It's rare to find a new release with good dynamic range.
>muh dynamic range
FDR releases sound like shit 9 out of 10 times
as long as there's no clipping, I'd rather have my shit sound bigger
this sounds better than any 80s album and i will die on that hill
May have been true when metal was nothing but an untalented sausage party. It's gotten better.
>Baby'Metal'
>Nu 'Metal'
>Glam 'Metal'
Not metal, fuck off back to hot topic
You don't know what you're talking about
>le BM is le surf rock because le tremolo
fuck off poser
Theres more to sound dynamics than volume. Regardless, plenty of bands like Isis, Paysage D'hiver, Opeth, Ulver, Deathspell Omega, early Judas Priest, etc. make frequent use of softer interludes and breaks.
Though if you're whining this much about volume. Sounds like you're just filtered and shouldn't bother.
>fuck off poser
but I like it
>uhuhu not REAL METUL
lol homosexual
what is the point of this thread?
to bait redditors for (you)s
why is OP trying to bait redditors on LULZ?
well metal spawned from proto metal (punk and post hardcore) so it makes sense it is basic and repetitive
?????
>can't refute my point
lol
JP - Sad Wings of Destiny, all of Black Sabbath's classic 70s albums, Pentagram's demos and Deep Purple - Deep Purple in Rock all predate any Punk/Hardcore.
Again, you don't know what you're talking about.
you listed proto metal bands heavily influenced by punk/post hardcore
don't feed the troll, anon
>JP - Sad Wings of Destiny, all of Black Sabbath's classic 70s albums, Pentagram's demos and Deep Purple - Deep Purple in Rock all predate any Punk/Hardcore.
None of that is metal, it's diapershit
No it isn't because metal always wants to innovate, it's often about one upping the competition to be the fastest, heaviest, weirdest etc. Metal is absolutely autustic about spawning new subgenres just because someone managed to mix it with something else. The amount of variety is insane but so is the amount of failed experiments.
listen to Opeth
>Isn't Metal a bit repetitive and lacking dynamics?
yeah like everything in life. I just listen to distorted surf rock (aka black metal) and it's good enough for me. I do like ordinary surf rock too btw.
*blocks your path*
kendall is my number one boy
no one itt knows what dynamics means
mu doesn't know shit about music
Yes and that is intended. Metal is based on riffs and is consistently loud.
sounds fucking awful. i'll stick to schumann
Sure, stick to what you like.
Black Metal never gets old
Listen to Teitanblood. Riff-focused but not repetitive, every album has its own identity, good lyrics too. Production is decent by metal standards, but that's not saying much.
Anon, you can't hate metal for sounding the same when Classical is the worst offender of all genres. Also repetition and stridency are not inherently bad things.
classical has the most dynamics and variation in song structure of all genres, retard
>variation in song structure
>classical
lmao
when you sum up 600 years of classical music it surely looks like there's a lot of variety but when you look at individual time periods there's basically 0 variation on forms
>but when you look at individual time periods there's basically 0 variation on forms
This is so wrong it's not even funny.
200 years of nothing but sonatas, operas and concertos says otherwise
The only one of those you listed that is a musical form is the sonata, both the opera and concerto are a genre that can contain many different forms. The sonata is also the only thing you listed that is a classical invention.
yeah, that's why only smug pretentious retards listen to that boomer crap. I have not met a single intelligent person who listened to classical music. Not one could even tell the difference between a differential and an integral or solve a basic pre-calculus limit function. Classical music is dumb and people who "enjoy" it are even dumber.
>Isn't Metal a bit repetitive and lacking dynamics? All sounds more or less the same and too much strident. Classical music and good Rock is 10000 times better than Metal.
Im going to give you a 6/10 for at least putting some effort into this metal bashing thread
no one composes classical music anymore except stupid ass avant garde contemporary classical. if youre still listening to 300 year old music as your only music source you lack musical taste
by 'good Rock' you probably mean 60s/70s/80s classic rock, again, youre living in the past. Modern rock is all commercial garbage
Yeah, metal sucks. If you want dynamics, post rock is a better option for you
>If you want dynamics, post rock is a better option for you
it's literally the same moody surf rock as black metal but with fewer distortions and more yuropoor doomer aesthetics. I would've thought you'd recommend something gayer, though; something like 'progressive' metal.
Interesting. When I listen to Talk Talk, Bark Psychosis, Swans, and Slint, I don’t hear “surf rock” at all. But at least we can agree on progressive metal being garbage
#
>Isn't Metal a bit repetitive and lacking dynamics?
Yes.
>good rock
Lol, its obvious you just want to shoe horn in your own preferred shitty genre into the conversation and appeal to the authority of classical. Like when someone shoehorns Jazz in with classical, pathetic behavior.
We all know classical is the ultimate form of music, or at least anyone of any intelligence who has spent at least some time thinking about music knows that. However... classical has no aggression, nor can it replicate the textures and instrumentation of metal. If you really enjoy ugly nasty distortion with an angry son-of-a-bitch howling in your ear, classical has no place for you. All there is are genres like metal, industrial, punk, and noise - of these only metal actually cares about being music first and foremost. At its best, metal is pretty good for its incredible limitations, and its still evolving to this day, getting better and better.
Its not the best music of all time, but it sure as hell the best music for its intended goal. Thats part of the reason people who listen to metal tend to only listen to metal unlike fans of other genres, because its about the unique aspects only metal has. Its easy to understand the purpose of metal, as for why people like things like Rock and Jazz which serve no real temperamental difference to classical, is beyond me; all you are doing is listening is a lesser form of music with nothing to stand on. Ironic that both genre fans tend to be elitest to metal fans when their chosen music is midwit central with little to no redeeming factors or purpose of existence.
This guy is an absolute turbovirgin sperg that everyone despises, don't listen to his godawful sporkcore recs
Holy shit, kill yourselves now
All music has repetition and I’ll bet you don’t care when it’s music you like.
Weenie waving about listening to the superior genre is just embarrassing and I am ashamed of your argument. You don't come to one genre trying to find the attributes of another, that's a recipe for remaining closed to new experiences. There's an amazing amount of variation within the genre of metal, once you acclimate yourself to it. Like some of the denser subgenres within "Classical", it yields structure upon repeated listening. I hope you get to have the experience because there's things in it you cannot find anywhere else.
good metal knows when to play slow and melodic.....the calm before the storm B] m/