all northern larping haplogroups are southern in origin. south colonising north was common through all european history, it is normal and completly natural, so you should not resist migration from middle east. remember that agricultural revolution was brought to europe by middle easterners
thx, another example of middle eastern civillisation influence on Europe, which made Europe truly great
No. Your map is wrong, sorry.
R1a and R1b came to southern Europe from the north in the late 4th and 3rd millennia BC. Germanic and Slavic subclades of Hg I also came from the north in the 1st millennium AD. To find any southern origin of Hg I you have to go way back to the Paleolithic.
From the East, really.
I wouldnt call Germany "The East"
if you mean through ANE, ok well Yana lived further north than is habitable today.
they were so far north half their homeland is under water and ice now.
IE migration paths till antiquity
source: my head
Mostly correct, but the Bell Beakers came from Corded Ware, not Yamnaya. BB and CWC both had Hg P312, which is a different branch from Yamnaya's Z2103. There was a big study on this in September 2021.
R1b in modern euros is Bell beaker, which is WHG in origin
Steppe r1b exists in yamnaya, and bell beakers descended from r1a corded ware, not yamnaya
No, R1b in west Europe is from EHG
Isn't oldest r1b in whg and not ehg?
Ehgs were 1/3 whg and they didn't live in western europe
>and bell beakers descended from r1a corded ware
Then why R1a is irrelevant in western europeans ? (from France to Iberian Peninsula, Italy or England)
That's not the homeland of R1b
True
Also northern and western europeans selected for the phenotype of the near eastern farmers that moved to the north
Funnelbeakers have nothing to do with Western Europeans.
Phenotypically they do, as a north EEF population
Those phenotypes don't exist in Western Europe anymore.
Phenotypically related doesn't mean identical
My point is, N and W europeans do not look like yamnaya or steppe maykop or other early steppe people. At all. Their phenotypes are mainly EEF variations and even look more like arabs than they do steppe
For reference
Steppe phenotype
Those "reconstructions" were made by a twink fetishist that loves Dagestani men. They never looked like that.
>so you should not resist migration from middle east.